NYC Liquid Eyeliner In Blackest Black | Review


I am totally an eyeliner (not a winged eyeliner though, just a simple stroke) obsessed female. When I was new to the application of eyeliner I first started with kohl pencil to do an eyeliner and then gel eyeliner. When I wanted to try liquid eyeliner, I was not sure whether I’ll be comfortable with the application or the liquid getting into my eyes so I purchased this super super affordable liquid eyeliner from New York Color. I have been using for more than an year now and realized I never did a review on this so here are my thoughts about this product.

There are two shades available in this one is black and the other one is pearlized black. I got in the shade black which is super intense jet black and flawless matte finish. It doesn’t bleed or feather on application. It goes on very smoothly and might take few seconds to dry completely. It doesn’t smudge at all and stays in place throughout the day. As it not waterproof nor does it claim to be, so this might fade little bit if you sweat. I am not sure how well this holds up if you were in a humid environment. The applicator is super, super thin and a bit elongated. This allows for more control than the average liquid eyeliner, but at the same time takes time to get used to because it’s so thin and flexible. Some people might not like this elongated applicator as there is no firm grip to hold it close and create a wing.


NYC Liquid Eyeliner Review

Overall, I love this liquid eyeliner and already used couple of them. I highly recommend to all of you who want affordable and super matte black liquid eyeliner. I’ll definitely keep repurchasing this over and over. If you are liquid eyeliner fan then you should definitely try this one.


  • Super affordable
  • Jet-black color
  • Super matte finish
  • Doesn’t smudge


  • Applicator is bit elongated

Price: $2.77

Rating: 4.9/5


Have you ever tried this one? What are your thoughts about this? Which is your favorite among eyeliners? Thanks for reading :)!

45 thoughts on “NYC Liquid Eyeliner In Blackest Black | Review

  1. Iqra says:

    This is an eyeliner that has been on my buy list for the longest time, the only problem is that the brand isn’t so easily available in the UK. So I’ll have to save it for a U.S beautyjoint order. I love how affordable it is though, especially for that great price and the pigmentation too ^_^

    Iqra | The Blushing Giraffe x

  2. Cy Palma says:

    I actually prefer more elongated applicators, because with the shorter ones, I get eyeliner all over my eyelashes and they stuck together and look really bad when I apply mascara! I really like the way this looks! Some of my favorite youtubers talk about this all the time and I’m really excited to get it!

    Cy | Dulce de Mango

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

CommentLuv badge